Random   •   Archives   •   RSS   •   About   •   Contact

Replace the Nagios Scheduler and NRPE with Salt Stack

Note: I will update this post as I progress.

So the idea is to use Salt Stack's remote execution to communicate with all nodes and run the Nagios checks and collect the return output instead of using the NRPE client/service protocol. This reduces the number of agents running on each host and appears significantly more secure. Salt Stack uses public/private crypto on top of the ZMQ publisher/subscriber model. This means the communication transport is very fast, very secure, and all nodes will run checks in parallel!

First, we need to install the Nagios checks and plugins on each host or minion.
I used the following State Formula on my Ubuntu and Debian hosts:


    - installed

    - installed


    - nagios.plugins

I kicked off a highstate (salt '*' state.highstate) on all minions and eventually they all returned in the affirmative. We now have all the Nagios plugins and checks installed on each host.

This next part is FUN, We run a check on every host concurrently.

This particular check counts the number of processes running on each host and warns at 150 and criticals at 200.

salt '*' --out=json --static cmd.run_all '/usr/lib/nagios/plugins/check_procs -w 150 -c 200'

Output static JSON - Wait for all minions to return and then generate a single JSON object.

    "graphite.foxhop.net": {
        "pid": 24356,
        "retcode": 0,
        "stderr": "",
        "stdout": "PROCS OK: 78 processes"
    "akuma.foxhop.net": {
        "pid": 4610,
        "retcode": 1,
        "stderr": "",
        "stdout": "PROCS WARNING: 158 processes"
    "ken.foxhop.net": {
        "pid": 31254,
        "retcode": 2,
        "stderr": "",
        "stdout": "PROCS CRITICAL: 392 processes"

Review the Nagios Plugin API for more information about return codes and STDOUT formats.

Last, we take this JSON data perform further processing or display it in a meaningful way.

For example, we could generate an HTML/JavaScript dashboard from the raw JSON objects. We could cut metrics out of the STDOUT and persist historic values in a data store. We could push the data into another system like Graphite or even send an email alerts.

This solution has all the perks of Nagios without ANY of the cons!

Returning the check output data to the CLI isn't super useful for further processing, so I hacked in a way to return data back to the master using the encrypted zeromq bus.


# -*- coding: utf-8 -*-
The zeromq returner will send return data back to the Salt Master over the
Encrypted 0MQ event bus with a custom tag for filtering on the other end.

Basically after the remote execution finishes, the ret data is "packaged" into
a special "envelope" which triggers the local Salt Minion Daemon to
forward the ret data to the Salt Master's event bus.

The "package" basically wraps the ret data and uses the tag 'fire_master'.

For example, a ret data object from the execution of test.ping
would be "packaged" like this::

  ret = {
    'graphite.foxhop.net': true

  ret['tag'] = 'third-party'

  package = {
    'events': [ ret ],
    'tag': None,
    'pretag': None,
    'data': None

The Salt Minion Daemon will forward this package to the Salt Master
where a 3rd party script may be filtering on the specified internal event tag.

To use the zeromq returner, append '--return zeromq' to the salt command. ex::

  salt --return zeromq '*' test.ping


 figure out a way for user to define custom tag for filtering ...
 Most returners use the Salt Minion config file to supply returner
 details... that is not optimal, it would be ideal if the custom tag
 could be supplied on the CLI when the remote execution is run, like::

   --return=zeromq --tag=mytag


# needed to log to log file
import logging

# needed for config to opts processing
import os
import salt.syspaths as syspaths
from salt.config import minion_config

# needed to send events over ZMQ
import salt.utils.event

log = logging.getLogger(__name__)

# needed to define the module's virtual name
__virtualname__ = 'zeromq'

def __virtual__():
    return __virtualname__

def returner(ret):
    Send the return data to the Salt Master over the encrypted
    0MQ bus with custom tag for 3rd party script filtering.

    # get opts from minion config file, supports minion.d drop dir!
    opts = minion_config(os.path.join(syspaths.CONFIG_DIR, 'minion'))

    # TODO: this needs to be customizable!
    tag = 'third-party'

    # add custom tag to return data for filtering
    ret['tag'] = tag

    # multi event example, supports a list of event ret objects.
    # single event does not currently expand/filter properly on Master side.
    package = {
      #'id': opts['id'],
      'events': [ ret ],
      'tag': None,
      'pretag': None,
      'data': None

    # opts must contain valid minion ID else it binds to invalid 0MQ socket.
    event = salt.utils.event.SaltEvent('minion', **opts)

    # Fire event payload with 'fire_master' tag which triggers the
    # salt-minion daemon to forward payload to the master event bus!
    event.fire_event(package, 'fire_master')

Next we run a third party application on the Salt Master which subscribes to our events by filtering on the special tag ('third-party').


# event libary for events over ZMQ
import salt.utils.event

# create event object, attach to master socket ...
event = salt.utils.event.MasterEvent('/var/run/salt/master')

tag = 'third-party'

print('Listening for events tagged \'{}\' on Salt Master bus.'.format(tag))

# generator iterator yields events forever, we filter on tag
for data in event.iter_events(tag=tag):

This small application just prints the incoming return data, but it could easily be expanded to process the incoming return data and persist it somewhere.

Open two terminals on the Salt Master host.

# on terminal 1 run:
python listen_to_master_bus.py
# on terminal 2 run:
salt '*' --return zeromq cmd.run_all '/usr/lib/nagios/plugins/check_procs -w 150 -c 200'

Same remote execution check as before but now our new returner will make data appear in terminal 1!

This zeromq returner is more of a proof-of-concept. I think the salt remote execution command line tool should allow end-users to provide a --tag so that data may be feed directly back to a third-party script listening to the Salt Master's event bus which filters on the particular tag. My next step is to look into what it would take to build in this functionality.

In the future I want to rig up the Salt scheduler to invoke these remote execution checks on a steady and predictable cadence. Nagios historically runs checks every 5 minutes. The Salt scheduler will allow us schedule different checks with different frequencies. For example, I might want my load checks and metrics to be collected every 10 secs, but my disk capacity usage checked every 2 minutes. This fine-grain control is super powerful!

Want comments on your site?

Remarkbox — is a free SaaS comment service which embeds into your pages to keep the conversation in the same place as your contentr. It works everywhere, even static HTML sites like this one!

Remarks: Replace the Nagios Scheduler and NRPE with Salt Stack

© Russell Ballestrini.